5

Best Car Battery 2017 [Reviews and Buyer’s Guide]

To help you out find the best car battery for your specific needs and budget, we've spent hundreds of hours doing research to craft this simple list comparing the 5 best performing car batteries 2017.

We've also reviewed each battery individually to let you know specs, the features we love, and the problems of each one.

Best Car Battery 2017

Car Battery Comparison Chart

Battery Name

CCA 

Ah 

RC 

Type 

Our Rating

Optima RED Top

880

n/a

100'

AGM

Optima Yellow Top

650

n/a

98'

AGM

Odyssey PC680

170

16

24'

AGM

ACDelco 94RAGM

800

80

140'

AGM

XS Power D3400

1000

65

n/a

AGM

Now if you own a car, some basic understanding about the battery does come in handy.

Specially to help you identify obvious signs that the battery is going to give up on you, or a simple question such as: Do they need maintenance?

We know it is hard to keep track of everything you should know about your car.

From the battery to engine oil to tyre pressure to winter emergency kits to how to replace headlights... It all can be a bit dauting. But don't worry, it really isn't that much, nor that hard!

On this article, you'll find enough information to help you buy the right car battery for you car.

Lastly, you’re going to find plenty of product recommendations to help put you on the right path to picking out the perfect car battery to meet all of your needs.

Why Replace The Car Battery?

From the most obvious to some you may not have thought about, there are a few key reasons you may want to replace your car's battery. Let's have a look at them:

It died. Gone. Kaputt.

This is perhaps the most obvious reason when it comes to trying to figure out why you might need a replacement.

You go turn the ignition one morning and nothing happens.

No crank movement, battery light on the dashboard is on...

Now of course it could be you left one light on during the night, couldn't it?

But if this happens a few mornings in a row... Sorry, your battery has left this life.

It Keeps Failing and How to troubleshoot a battery that fails.

Actually, before that first scenario happens, we're very likely to find this one first.

It is extremely important to spot this signs when they happen so we can work in advance and replace the battery before it left us stranded the day we are really late to work or we've got a flight to catch.

Sign 1: When we turn the ignition key, the engine cranks slowly.

Probably the lights on the dashboard dim and the needles on the meters dance or stay down when the engine finally turns on. Extremely clear sign of dying battery

Sign 2: Dimming lights and unstable idle.​

Engine does turn on but it seems to have a hard time staying like that, and you percieve the lights dimming.

Either battery is close to die, or the alternator isn't charging.

There's one quick way to troubleshoot the latter: Get your multimeter and measure volts on the battery terminals when the engine is on. Should be 13.8v on idle and 14.7v if you give it some gas.

If it is lower than that, it's the alternator. Alternator charges good?

Then get yourself a new battery.

Upgraded Car Electronics or other electric features.

When we add extra electronic equipment to our cars such as a new stereo, perhaps a fancy double din unit with GPS, and maybe a 4 channel amplifier to power up those brand new speakers you got on Amazon and you're thinking of getting a subwoofer too to get that final depth of sound to enjoy every track as if it were live in concert, you may want to upgrade your battery.

Not just that, but electric powered doors, aftermarket heated wing mirrors, light bars and such stuff increase the electric consumption and you need a bigger, more powerful source. 

So if you find yourself in any of those three scenarios, have a look at the following product reviews which will allow you to know which are the best ones you can buy right now.

Car Battery Reviews

1. Optima Batteries RED Top

Optima RedTop Battery Review

It was quite clear Optima was going to be our first, most recommended choice.

Either the RedTop for general purposes, or the YellowTop (nº2 on this list) for a more complete, rounded performance. 

Specs

For the specifications of this particular battery, you’re going to get a 12-volt battery with 800 cold cranking amps and the measurements of this particular battery are 10” x 6 7/8" x 7 13/16” and it has dual SAE & GM posts as well.

Optima Batteries use an exclusive technology that makes them the top player right now. It is called Spiralcell.

It also comes with a reserve capacity of around 100 minutes of constant performance and the battery also is sure to deliver you optimal starting power no matter what conditions it might face, including extreme cold temperatures and bad weather.

One of the biggest problems with some batteries lies in the fact that the vibration of the car can cause some serious problems to the battery.

However, this battery is fifteen times more resistant to vibrations, which makes it a great choice for strength and durability.

EDITOR'S RATING:

Optima RedTop features

Does it fit your car?

When it comes to fitting, as always, make sure you know the size of your battery box, and that you know on which side you have your Positive and Negative terminals.

In this battery in particular, you'll find positive on the bottom left. If still unsure, use Amazon's "will it fit" tool or check customer's reviews using the blue button on top.

These are a topseller and most likely people that own the very same car you do have them installed.

Pros

Cons

2. Optima Batteries Yellow Top

Optima Yellowtop battery review

Another absolute best seller is the Yellow Top from Optima.

And it's quite clear why: They rock.

Meant for deep cycling, this is the perfect battery for those with a lot of lightbars and leds and foglights and sound systems and what not on their cars.

Being just slightly more expensive than the Red Top, we would call this one the Best Car Battery of the year, overall.

Specs

Once again talking about the specifications of this particular battery, you’re going to enjoy a 12 volt battery with 650 cold cranking amps.

It weighs in at a pretty average weight of just over 36 pounds and it measures 9 5/16” x 6 13/16” x 7 5/8".

When it comes to the measurements, always make sure that you measure carefully or consult a guide to make sure that it is going to fit your vehicle properly.

This battery also has a 98 minute reserve capacity so that it can deliver consistent performance to your car without skipping a beat.

Similar to the battery above this one, it also has a new feature that allows it to be 15 times more resistant to the vibrations that it experiences in the car, which means that it is going to do it’s job much more efficiently.

EDITOR'S RATING:

optima battery specs
Optima yellow top internal structure

The battery is also wired to make sure that you’re going to have optimal starting power no matter what situation you might find yourself in.

Whether it is cold weather or just bad weather all around, the battery should start up with little to no problems at all thanks to the cold cranking amps included in the battery.

Pros

Cons

3. Odyssey PC680

Odyssey PC680 Battery Review

When it comes to buying a battery for your car, you might want to consider buying one of the cheaper batteries on the market because odds are good that you’re not gonna wanna spend a ton of money.

This is a great battery choice for the money and it does offer some features that you’re going to appreciate.

Specifically, the warranty offered on this battery is one of the best out of any other battery that we reviewed on this post. I

t comes with a limited 2-year full replacement warranty so that if anything goes wrong and it is covered by the warranty, you will receive a full replacement, not just parts.

Specs

The CCA on this battery is definitely one of the lower ones out of what we have reviewed so far but it does have a longer cycle life because when compared to other batteries, it is an average of 70% longer than the conventional batteries that it was compared again and it has up to 400 cycles at 80%.

EDITOR'S RATING:

When compared to any sealed lead battery on the market, you’ll find that this battery has the highest recharge efficiency out of any of the other.

It will recharge 100% in just 4-6 hours and can be mounted flexibly and has a non-spillable design.

The measurements of this particular unit come in at 7.3” x 3.1” x 6.7”.

In addition to everything discussed above, this particular battery also has vibration resistance so that it will be protected against high impact shock and vibrations that are caused by the movement of the car.

Additionally, temperature has no effect on this battery as it is resistant to most extreme temperatures. We name this battery the best car battery for the money.

Pros

Cons

4. ACDelco 94RAGM

AC Delco AGM Battery Review

This is our recomendation for truck owners.

With 800 CCA, starting a big fat diesel engine will be no problem even on extreme cold weather.

And with those powerful 140Ah, you can power a 22" lightbar, or a badass subwoofer with zero trouble, no dimming headlights.. nothing. Just power!.

A massive lot of value for your money with this AC Delco battery. We really like AC Delco for heavy duty parts. 

This battery has a high density negative pasts and it works to improve the performance of the battery while also increasing the longevity and the life of it as well.

The enhanced life alloy and silver calcium stamped allot not only looks great but it also helps to increase the cycle life and the overall performance of the battery as well. In addition, the calcium lead positive grid means that conductivity is maximised and allows for some of the lowest resistance.

EDITOR'S RATING:

AC Delco AGM Specs

As if all of those features weren’t enough to sell you on this particular product, you’re going to love the Robust Envelope Separator that has a puncture-resistant back to allow for more acid circulation and less shorts.

The reasons for this is because the battery is kept much cooler, meaning that it will have a longer life and will not have to work as hard as a hot battery might have to.

Will it fit my car?

This particular unit measures in at about 12.4” x 6.9” x 7.5”, so make sure that you take the time to measure your vehicle and make sure that this battery fits in there perfectly. While it isn’t a huge deal with the exception of carrying it to the car, the battery weighs about 51.6 pounds, which makes it one of the heavier choices on the list.

Pros

Cons

5. XS Power D3400

XS Power D3400 Battery Review

If price doesn’t matter at all and you really only care about finding a battery that packs in the most power out of any of the other batteries you’ll find, then this is going to be the battery you’re going to want to own.

It is easily one of the most powerful batteries out of any of the ones discussed on this list and a quick look at the full features of the battery will confirm that.

It is a 12 volt battery that packs in 1000 CCA and 65 amp hours to deliver what could be one of the most powerful battery experiences that you’re going to find throughout your entire search.

This battery is absorbed glass mat, which means that the electrolyte is suspended in fiberglass.

In addition to those great features, you’re going to enjoy the fact that is is spill proof, sealed, valve regulated and is vibration resistant to make sure that you don’t have any problems with the battery that would normally be caused by vibrations in the engine area.

Will it fit my car?

When you’re paying the good money that you would be paying for a battery like this, it’s truly important to make sure that you are getting exactly what you want.

EDITOR'S RATING:

In this case, it’s important to know that the battery as a whole measures 11.7” x 8.2” x 10.7”, which means it’s the perfect size to fit in your car, but always make sure you measure ahead of time.

Last but certainly not least when it comes to the features of the battery, you’re also going to get an ultra low internal resistance to make sure that no matter what happens to the battery, it’s going to withstand what it needs to.

Furthermore, this battery is incredibly easy to mount and install in just about any position, so you can do what you want to do in order to make sure the battery is mounted easily.

This is the best battery for car audio.

XS Power batteries have a lot of appreciation on the competitive scene.​

Pros

Cons

Extra: Best Auxiliary Battery

Best Auxiliary Battery: Kinetik HC800 BLU

Kinetic HC Blue Car Battery Review

Perhaps one of the better values out of any of the other batteries that were reviewed on this post, this particular battery is available at a very affordable price and we have even found that it can really make a difference if you decide to want to save some money but still get a good battery.

There are several different battery models available, which is really helpful because that means the odds are good that you’ll be able to find the perfect size fit in your vehicle.

For the sake of ease, the remainder of this review is going to discuss the HC800 model, which measures in at about 6.5 inches by 8 inches by 5.5 inches.

Since it happens to be one of the smaller batteries, it weighs in at just 23 pounds, one of the lightest out of all the ones on this post.

The looks of the battery is second to none as it comes in a beautiful black case with a blue logo that looks great from just about anywhere.

EDITOR'S RATING:

Additionally, this particular battery has an 800 watt maximum power cell along with a 12V high current power cell to make sure that you’re really getting everything that you can out of the battery.

The design of this battery is great in the fact that it has a sealed absorbed glass mat design which means that you get a great battery that is built to last.

This is a great choice as a secondary or auxiliary battery if you run a powerful car audio setup. 

Pros

Cons

Car Battery Buyer's Guide

lead-acid battery

As mentioned earlier, we understand that not everyone is going to know everything they should know when it comes to car batteries and that’s where this is going to come in handy for you. The following is some of the top things you should look for when it comes to car batteries so that you know exactly what you want.

Battery Types

When it comes to battery types, there are essentially two main types that you’re going to need to know about.

Those are the lead acid batteries and the AGM batteries.

The lead acid batteries have both Starting and Deep Cycle batteries.

The starting is designed to give quick bursts of energy while the deep cycle has less instant energy but it is a greater choice for long-term energy.

AGM batteries are short for Absorbed Glass Mat and that essentially means that it allows the electrolytes to remain suspended closely to the plates active material.

This works to enhance both the recharge and the discharge efficiency so that you get a better overall experience with your battery.

 Buyer's Guide

Performance

To know how good is a battery going to perform, there are two key features we can look at to understand how much power we can expect from a car battery:

Cold Cranking Amps

When talking about car batteries, CCA stands for Cold Cranking Amps.

If you don’t know what that means, essentially it is measured by testers putting the battery in a cold climate and then measure how large the discharge load is for a new, charge battery in 30 seconds.

The reason a cold climate is chosen is because often times, a battery is going to be at it’s worst performance condition when it is in the cold climate, so if it performs well in the cold, then it should perform well in just about any situation.

Despite the importance of the CCA when it comes to cold temperatures, it is probably not worth basing your decision on that particular unit of measure.

However, if you live in a climate that is cold for a considerable amount of time, you should put a lot more weight into the CCA than anyone else.

Ah (Amps*h)

For car batteries, Ah stands for amp hour and is a standarized measure for batteries.

Typically, you’re going to find that the amp rating is taken for 20 hours. So if you have a 100 Ah rated battery, that means that for 20 hours, it will draw about 100 amps, which would then translate to about 5 amp hours.

What To Look For If You Have A High-Demand System

If you have a high-demand system such as, lets say, four 70w RMS speakers powered by a 4 channel amplifier and a monoblock amplifier for a 2000w RMS 12 inch subwoofer and a 24" lightbar and xenon headlights... a regular battery won't serve you. You are looking then for a deep-cycle battery such as the Optima Yellow top, and most likely an auxiliary battery like the Kinetic 800 to power all that.

Besides, such a big setup will require you to upgrade the big 3 if you really want to get the most out of your system.

With that practical example we mean the following:

Know how power-hungry (watts) are the aftermarket components you install in your car. Get a battery that will power it accordingly or you're in for some baaaad performance.​

Wrapping Up

As you can see, there is a lot of thought and consideration that needs to go into choosing a car battery.

Whether it has to do with the total output you’re looking for or the size of the battery, it can be tough if you have never done something like this before. 

Above is a great guide to make sure that you find everything you could possibly need when it comes to buying the best car battery.

If you have any questions, just write a comment below!

Alex Meyer
 

Alex Meyer is a 26-year-old Certified Automotive Technician with over 10 years experience as a mechanic and car audio installer. He shares his knowledge at Gear4wheels.com

Click Here to Leave a Comment Below 5 comments
Scroll Up